Hiring Contractors and Gig Workers: What We Suggest Small Businesses Screen Before the First Job
An independent contractor background check is the one small businesses most often skip, on the theory that the person is not an employee and therefore not the company's problem. The customer whose home the contractor enters does not see the distinction. Neither, in most cases, does the law that governs background reports. After decades of helping small businesses order background checks online, we have watched the contractor share of their workforce grow while the screening of those workers lagged behind. Here is what we suggest screening before a contractor's first job, and the rules that apply. This is general information rather than legal advice; an employment attorney can confirm what applies in your state.
Contractor or employee is a tax question, not a screening question
The IRS draws the line by control: a worker is generally an independent contractor if the business has the right to control or direct only the result of the work and not what will be done or how (IRS), weighing behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship (IRS Topic 762). That classification determines tax withholding and benefits. It has very little to do with whether the person will be alone in a customer's house, driving a vehicle with your name on it, or handling payment information. Screen for the risk of the work, not the label on the tax form.
The FCRA still applies
The Fair Credit Reporting Act's rules for reports used for 'employment purposes' are not limited to W-2 employees. The FTC staff concluded in a 1998 advisory opinion that a trucking operation using consumer reports to decide whether to engage individuals as drivers, even as independent contractors, must comply with the FCRA's employment-purpose provisions, including the disclosure and authorization requirements (FTC Allison opinion), and the agency's staff report on the Act states that the term is interpreted liberally and may apply where a business uses individuals who are not technically employees to perform duties (FTC staff report, p. 32). The practical rule is simple: give contractors the same standalone disclosure, get the same written authorization, and follow the same pre-adverse and adverse action steps you would for an employee (FTC).
What to screen, by the work being done
A contractor who writes code remotely and a contractor who installs appliances in customers' kitchens do not need the same reports. We suggest matching the search to the exposure:
Identity and address history for everyone, so the person who shows up is the person who was screened and the criminal search covers the right counties.
County and national criminal searches, plus a sex offender registry check, for anyone entering homes, working around children or vulnerable adults, or working alone with customers.
A motor vehicle record for anyone driving to jobs in a company vehicle or being reimbursed to drive their own.
Professional license and insurance verification for trades that require them, checked against the issuing board rather than a photocopy.
Employment or client verification for contractors whose pitch rests on past work, confirming the engagements actually happened.
Address history matters more for contractors than for most hires because they tend to move between markets. We explained how the trace drives the county search in Verifying a Candidate's Prior Addresses.
Platforms and agencies do not screen for you
A contractor found through a marketplace, staffing agency or referral network may or may not have been screened, and the screening may have been years ago or limited to a single database. Ask what was run, when and against which identifiers, and get it in writing. If the answer is vague, run your own. Any report you rely on for your decision should be one you can produce if asked.
Criminal records: decide by the job
When a record appears, evaluate it against the work the contractor will do: what the offense was, how long ago, and how it relates to entering homes, handling money or driving. The EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance recommending that approach in October 2026, while stating that the rescission does not require employers to abandon lawful practices adopted under it and that Title VII continues to prohibit discrimination based on race or national origin (EEOC). Several states and cities have fair-chance laws, some of which reach contractors; counsel can tell you which apply where you operate. Whatever standard you set, write it down and apply it to every contractor doing the same kind of work.
Rescreen when the engagement changes
A contractor hired for a one-week project who is still on the schedule two years later has become a long-term relationship with a two-year-old report. Treat a change in access, a move into driving, or a fixed interval for high-trust work as the trigger for a new check, the same way we described for employees in Rescreening Current Employees. Keep the authorization language broad enough to cover it, or get a fresh signature.
Small businesses can order criminal searches, address history, SSN verification, driving records and other reports for contractors online, pay per report with no monthly fees or minimums, on our employment screening page.
Comments